Opinion
by Consumer Advocate
Tim Bolen
Tuesday,
February 27th, 2007
Every practitioner in the United
States knows that the current
US Department of Health & Human Services (DHHS)
billing code system doesn't work. A whole industry has sprung up around
the simple fact that it doesn't work, trying desperately to keep practitioners
out of trouble when they attempt to wend their way through the billing miasma.
And, a miasma it is.
Worse, is that the system, cumbersome and
confusing, has been contracted out, region by region, to insurance
companies - and not necessarily "health" insurance companies, for
management. In Los Angeles, for instance, several years ago, when a
billing person in a practitioner's office called "Medicare" on the
telephone to get assistance, the phone was answered by an employee of a
Title Insurance
Company.
US Medicare has NO FEDERAL
EMPLOYEES. None. It is all contracted out.
Yes, I said
Title Insurance
. Title insurance is
protection against loss arising from problems connected to the title to your
real estate property (like your home).
Scary? Yes, that is. And
even scarier is that those Medicare contractors' employees and even the
practitioner's billing staff are offered cash incentives to rat on their
employers when they can identify
"fraudulent claims." Practitioners walk a difficult line, trying
to bill Medicare, Medicaid, or health insurance using the DHHS system
developed by and for physicians. Accusations of fraud are flung easily -
since the government rewards whistle-blowers and collects a whooping $10,000
per claim in penalties against those who bill incorrectly - including the
Medicare and Medicaid contractors. No wonder insurance companies are
reluctant to cover alternative medicine practitioners. There's good money, for
anyone to snitch on a
practitioner who uses the wrong codes or on an insurance company who processes
an incorrectly coded claim.
I'm not surprised when I hear
that health practitioners drop out of the system in waves. They just
don't need the hassle. Take a system that is "sketchy" at best, designed
by bureaucratic dolts in an agency that has little, or no, concept of its role
- DHHS - and severely penalize those who have to use it - and you have a
formula for disaster.